Reynolds was another 2024/25 summer signing for Jake Poole arriving from Nottingham Forest Women. Reynolds clocked up over 65 appearances for her previous club, following a spell at Reading FC Women in the Women's Super League. Last season, Reynolds scored five goals and created four others for team-mates in 20 FAWNL Division One Midlands appearances and also scored once and produced two assists in the Adobe Women's FA Cup campaign. The no-nonsense midfielder labels herself as a “bulldog in midfield,” breaking up play whilst driving the ball forward too.